New Regulations for n-Propyl Bromide (nPB) Solvents
Reliance Specialty Products wants to let you know about regulatory changes that are happening with n-Propyl Bromide and how we can help if you decide you want to switch-out of nPB or improve your cleaning equipment.
nPB is now REGULATED under NESHAP and is considered a Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP)
There are now Air Permitting and State Reporting Impacts
There will be Shipping Classification Impacts
There will be Waste Disposal Impacts
You can continue to use nPB. There is no immediate need to move out of nPB, but you may need to change permitting.
How Reliance Can Help:
We can help you switch into AeroTron™-100, a safer solvent, as we have done for many of our current nPB customers. We can provide a sample and test clean parts in AeroTron™-100.
Next, Reliance can also help you with assessing your current vapor degreaser and recommending upgrades or modifications.
nPB is now considered a HAP under NESHAP.
AeroTron™-100 is a direct nPB replacement that does not require permits or reporting.
nPB is REGULATED under NESHAP, the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants by the US EPA and is now considered a Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP).
Unexpectedly, on January 5th, 2022, n Propyl Bromide became a HAP (Hazardous Air Pollutant) regulated under NESHAP. The specifics of how it will be regulated under NESHAP will be provided by the US EPA at some time in the future.
As a side note:
No solvents have otherwise been added to NESHAP since it was originally enacted in the late 1990's - so no one knows what the requirements will be or what the time-frame for issuance is. However, we anticipate that the use requirements will be similar to TCE, PERC and Methylene Chloride that were part of that early regulation.
Implications of NESHAP Regulation of nPB
First, there are Air Permitting and State Reporting Impacts
nPB was formerly only a VOC (Volatile Organic Compound), but not a HAP under NESHAP. Therefore, the type of operating permit you currently have is likely a simple air-operating permit for VOC emission. If you decide to stay with n Propyl Bromide, you will need to switch-over to a HAP operating permit.
Permits are issued by each state and each state's permitting rules vary. For a HAP, there are typically small emitter permits and large emitter permits known as Title 5 permits.
The HAP permits typically are more expensive and require periodic reporting to establish compliance with the HAP requirements and report the amount of HAP's emitted. HAP permits also require more comprehensive vapor degreaser containment features and operating procedures. As mentioned earlier, specific requirements under the NESHAP regulations for nPB are not yet issued.
Also, each state's DEQ, Department of Environmental Quality, will need to address the re-permitting and final reporting requirements for nPB now that it is a HAP.
The second implication of NESHAP is Shipping Classification Impacts
nPB is currently not regulated for shipment. However, it is likely to be classified by the DOT as hazardous for shipment at some point and treated in the same manner as TCE, MC & PERC. Our understanding is that this will occur as a separate action by the DOT (Department of Transportation).
The third implication of NESHAP classification is Waste Disposal Impacts
Currently, nPB is not a RCRA hazardous waste for disposal. RCRA is the Federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. However, we anticipate in a similar manner to the other NESHAP solvents, n Propyl Bromide will likely be classified as a RCRA hazardous waste for disposal.
The bottom line is YOU CAN STILL USE NPB EVEN THOUGH IT IS NESHAP REGULATED
You can continue use nPB. Companies have been using TCE, PERC and MC under NESHAP for 25 years. And NESHAP in and of itself does not preclude continued use, it is just more involved.
Immediately, the main issue with nPB is your state air permitting (as discussed earlier). Since each state handles its own air VOC, HAP permitting, you will need to check with your state for their immediate requirements for re-permitting of nPB.
TSCA 6A - UPCOMING ADDITIONAL REGULATION OF nPB, TCE, PERC AND MC
The regulation of nPB, TCE, PERC and MC is underway under TSCA 6A, the Toxic Substances Control Act. This regulation gives the US EPA broad authority to regulate - and is capable of resulting in a phase-out or ban of n propyl bromide or any of the other solvents they are considering. A ban, if it occurs, would likely have a phase-out period.
TCE a couple of years ago was proposed banned for vapor degreasing. The USEPA Proposal was 18 months for phase out of manufacturing and a 36 month phase out for use. Thus, there was a 3-year period. The earlier proposal for TCE was withdrawn and is now again going through the process under TSCA 6 A along with nPB, PERC and MC.
Proposed regulations under TSCA 6A for nPB, TCE, PERC and Methylene Chloride are expected to be issued this year 2022.
Conclusion
There is no immediate need to move out of nPB, but you may need to change permitting immediately or when your State otherwise requires it. You will need to comply with the HAP permit reporting. The TSCA 6A is still in process and what the regulation of nPB will be under that regulation or if a phase out is part of it is unknown.
Here is how Reliance Can Help:
First, we can help you switch into AeroTron™-100, a safer solvent, as we have done for many of our current nPB customers. AeroTron™-100 is the next generation solvent that is a direct, drop-in replacement for nPB.
Next, Reliance can also help you with assessing your current vapor degreaser and recommending upgrades or modifications.
Please give us a call at 847.640.8923 or Contact Us for additional information.
We can test clean sample parts for you in AeroTron™-100 or
We can provide you with a sample of the AeroTron™-100 or
We are available for a technical consultation to help you navigate options.
Reliance takes a comprehensive approach to helping you assess your situation and your options.
We look forward to working with you.
Content protected by copyright: Reliance Specialty Products, Inc.
All Rights Reserved
AeroTron™-100 Means Improved Health & Safety Profile - 150 PPM
Excellent Health, Safety and Regulatory Profile As Compared to nPB
AeroTron™-100 Benefits are Significant:
No Air Permitting or Reporting - not considered a Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP)
Excellent Workplace Recommendation - Very favorable workplace recommendation of 150 ppm TLV-TWA for AeroTron™-100 compared to .10ppm for nPB.
No Toxicity - n Propyl Bromide is a suspected human carcinogen based on recent test results from the NTP and n Propyl Bromide has reproductive toxicity. AeroTron™-100's components do not have these characteristics, making it a safer replacement for nPB.
No Hydrolysis Reaction - n Propyl Bromide is vulnerable to creating acid in the presence of water and is stabilized against this. The amount of stabilizer in nPB needs to be tested frequently to make sure there are sufficient stabilizers in the solution. AeroTron™-100 is stable in the presence of water.
Better Performance - similar to nPB in that:
No residue & fast evaporating
Azeotropic formulation
Not subject to NESHAP regulation
Does not require special reporting
Ships via common carrier
Can be used in your current vapor degreasing equipment
Regulatory | AeroTron™-100 | nPB |
---|---|---|
NESHAP Reporting | Not Required | Required |
Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP) Reporting | None - Not Required | Required |
IARC Cancer Classification | None - Not Listed | Suspected |
Manufacturer's Workplace Exposure Guidelines | 150 ppm - 8 hour TWA | 10 ppm - 8 hour TWA |
RCRA | NON-Hazardous Waste | NON-Hazardous Waste |
Department of Transportation (DOT) | NOT Regulated | NOT Regulated |
Title V Permit | NOT Required | NOT Required |
OSHA HAZCOM Record Keeping/Reporting | NOT Required | Hazard Warning Required |
Prop 65, CA | Yes | Yes |
Clean Water Act | NOT Regulated | NOT Regulated |
VOC | Yes, but variable | Yes, 100% |
US-EPA SNAP Approved | Yes | Yes |
AeroTron™-100 Plastic Compatability Testing
Plastic | AeroTron™-100 Resistance | Plastic | AeroTron™-100 Resistance |
---|---|---|---|
POM | Excellent | HDPE | Excellent |
ABS | Poor | PEI | Excellent |
CPVC | Fair | PPO | Poor |
ETFE | Excellent | PP | Fair |
NYL | Excellent | PS | Poor |
PBT | Excellent | PSU | Poor |
PEEK | Excellent | PVC | Poor |
PVDF | Excellent | PU | Fair |
PC | Fair | PTFE | Excellent |
AeroTron™-100 Metal Compatability Testing
METHODS MIL.T-81533A 4.4.9 and TMO193-2000
Metal | AeroTron™-100 Compatible | Metal | AeroTron™-100 Compatible |
---|---|---|---|
Aluminum 1050 | Yes | Mild Steel | Yes |
Al-Bronze 614 | Yes | Carbon Steel | Yes |
Copper | Yes | Stainless 303 | Yes |
Naval Brass 464 | Yes | Stainless 316 | Yes |
Tin-Bronze 903 | Yes | Stainless 330 | Yes |
Tin | Yes | Tungsten-Carbide | Yes |
Hastalloy-B | Yes | 5 Sn/95 Pb | Yes |
Inconel 600 | Yes | 70 Sn/30 Pb | Yes |
Nickel | Yes | Titanium 5-2.5 | Yes |
Zinc | Yes | Silver Solder B AG8 | Yes |
Lead | Yes | Silver | Yes |
Magnesium | Yes | Gold | Yes |
Easy Change Over to AeroTron™-100
Essentially:
DRAIN: the vapor degreaser sumps (using solvent transfer pump), spray reserve tank, water separator and filtration tank of old solvent.
SET: the temperature control settings for 116 F (47 C)
FILL: the boil sump and immersion sump with AeroTron™-100
Performance Properties | AeroTron™-100 | nPB |
---|---|---|
Boiling Point | 116° F / 47° C | 160° F / 71° C |
Flash Point, by ASTM D93-TCC | None | None |
Evaporation Rate | Quickly & Completely | Quickly |
Azeotropic Composition | Yes | Yes |
Broad Metal Compatibility | Yes | Yes |
Hydrolysis | Highly Stable | Not stable-requires stabilizers |
Distillable | Yes | Yes |
Kauri Butanol Value | 93 | 130 |
Non-Volatile Residue | < 10 ppm | < 10 ppm |
Odor | Very Mild | Strong |
-
-
-
Reliance also manufactures the ULTRA™ line of vapor degreasing equipment to provide our customers a simple comprehensive cleaning package for your company.
LEARN MORE
Use AeroTron™-100 As An Alternative to nPB for Asphalt Extraction
Because AeroTron™-100 is non-flammable, it is suitable for use in any asphalt extraction process. It is very fast acting and removes the bitumen / tar easily from samples. AeroTron™-100 can be used as a direct nPB replacement in asphalt extractions.